Craftsman home with a warm front porch at golden hour

The short answer: price it right from the start. It's the most natural instinct in selling — "let's aim high, we can always come down." But in real estate, the come-down almost never catches up. The homes that start at the right price are the ones that sell fastest and, very often, for the most money.

Why do sellers want to price high?

Three reasons, and all of them feel sensible: leave room to negotiate, test the market "just in case" someone falls in love with it, and match what a neighbor got for a house that isn't quite the same house. The problem isn't the logic — it's what buyers actually do.

What really happens when a home is overpriced?

  • Most buyers never see it. Buyers search in price ranges. Price your home above its range and it doesn't show up in the searches of the people who would actually buy it — while the buyers who do see it are comparing it against genuinely nicer homes.
  • The first two weeks are your best weeks. A new listing gets its biggest surge of showings and online views right after it hits the market. Overpricing spends that surge on the wrong audience.
  • Days on market send a signal. The longer a home sits, the more buyers ask "what's wrong with it?" — and the lower their offers get. A price cut at day 40 doesn't reset the clock; buyers can see the history.
  • You end up chasing the market down. Cut, wait, cut again — while paying the mortgage, taxes, insurance, and upkeep the whole time. Homes that start high routinely sell for less in the end than they would have at the right price on day one.
  • The appraisal still has to work. Even if a buyer agrees to your high price, their lender orders an appraisal. If it comes in low, you're renegotiating anyway — from a weaker position.

But what if I price it too low?

This is the fear that drives overpricing, and it's mostly unfounded. Price a good home a little under the market and the market corrects it for you — more showings, more competition, and offers that bid it back up to its real value, sometimes past it. You can underprice and still get full value. You cannot overprice your way to extra money; you just get fewer buyers and a longer wait.

So how do we land on the right price?

Not by guessing, and not by what you need out of the sale. The right price comes from what similar homes near you have actually sold for recently — adjusted honestly for your home's condition, updates, and location — and from how much competition you'll have the week you list. That's a conversation worth having before the sign goes in the yard, not after the third price cut.

Thinking about selling?

Mitch & Sheila will run the numbers on your home and give you a straight answer on what it should list for — no obligation. Call or text 515-371-5002, or start at https://www.dunn-realtors.com.